Use of Chelates for Correcting Iron Chlorosis in Avocados Growing in
Calcareous Soils in
Costas Gregoriou
C.
Gregoriou
Agricultural
Research Institute,
M.
Papademetriou
Department
of Agriculture,
L.
Christofides
Government Farm, Kbufeiia,
SUMMARY
Lime induced chlorosis is a serious problem with
avocado grown on calcareous soils in
INTRODUCTION
Chlorosis of avocado is a serious problem under
certain conditions. It is most common on calcareous soils, and as a result it
is often referred to as "lime-induced chlorosis." Such chlorosis is
more critical to avocados on a worldwide scale than to any other fruit crop (Malo, 1976).
In
The best method to avoid lime-induced chlorosis would
be to avoid planting avocados on highly calcareous soils, or to use rootstocks
which are resistant to lime-induced chlorosis. Such rootstocks belong to the
West Indian race (Bergh, 1975 and Kadman and Ben-Ya'acov, 1982).
The only means to control chlorosis in already
established orchards is soil application of Fe-chelates,
since applications by foliar sprays have not been successful on a commercial
scale and iron compound injections are not practical (Kadman and Lahav, 1971).
Soil applications of various iron salts and soil acidifying agents, either
alone or in combinations, failed to give satisfactory results until the
introduction of chelated iron compounds in the early
1950's.
There are many chelates
available, but few are really effective under alkaline or calcareous
conditions. The purpose of this experimental work was to test a number of
Fe-sources at different rates for control of chlorosis in avocados.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Variety, location, and cultural practices
Trees of the Hass variety, 10 years old, on Mexican
race rootstock grown at Kouklia Government Farm of
the Department of Agriculture, were used.
The soil was a well drained sandy-clay loam with a
CaCO3 content of 35% and a pH of 8.2 (measured on a 1:2.5 soil:water suspension). The
specific conductivity of a saturated soil extract at 25°C was 0.8, 1.1, and 2.0 mmhos/cm at depths of 30, 60, and 90
cm, respectively.
The irrigation water used had a pH of 7.3 and an
electrical conductivity of 0.8 mmhos/cm.
It contained on average 665 ppm of total soluble
salts, including 62 ppm Cl, 60 ppm
Na, 78 ppm Ca, 27 ppm Mg,
82 ppm SO4, and 337 ppm
HCO3. Usually, 20 cubic meters of water per tree were applied during
the irrigation season at a frequency of one application per week.
Annual applications of ammoniun
sulphate, triple superphosphate,
an potassium sulfate were applied at the rate of 3.0
kg, 0.5 kg, and 1.0 kg per tree, respectively. Soil application of Chelene (Fe-chelate) at the rate
of 100 g per tree was used in spring 1980.
The degree of chlorosis of each tree was recorded in
February 1981 (Table 1). A scale from 1 to 11 was used to evaluate the degree
of chlorosis of tree canopy. According to the degree of chlorosis, the trees
were separated into the following four categories (see following page):
The treatments were applied to single-tree plots in a
completely ran-domed design with 9 replications. There were three replications
with severely chlorotic trees and two each with
moderately chlorotic, slightly chlorotic,
and healthy trees.
The Fe compounds were applied in two split
applications, one in early May and the other in early June of the years 1981
and 1982. This time of the year is the flushing period of avocado in
The principal measure of effectiveness of the various
treatments was a visual rating of each tree for iron deficiency symptoms. This
was done by two observers at intervals of approximately every two months. The
rating scale was from 1 to 11, as previously described.
|
Category |
Rating Scale |
Description
of Leaf Symptoms |
|
Healthy trees |
1-2 |
Practically all leaves
normal green. None with green veination of Fe
deficiency. |
|
Slightly chlorotic
trees |
3-5 |
Some leaves pale green,
approximately 10% with green veination. |
|
Moderately chlorotic
trees |
6-8 |
Many leaves
pale or yellowish green, approximately 50% with green veination. |
|
Severely chlorotic
trees |
9-11 |
Practically all leaves
yellowish green, more than 75% showing green veination,
many with necrotic margins, and shoots die-back. |
Leaf samples were taken in September 1981 and
analyzed for iron concentration. The crop was harvested in February and the
yield of each experimental tree was recorded in kgrs.
Also in October, the trunk circumference of each tree was measured at a fixed
point 15 cm above the bud union.
Treatments and experimental design
Five Fe sources were tested at three levels.
Equivalent amounts of Fe were applied with all sources at each rate. The Fe
sources and their rates were as follows:
|
Fe-source |
% Fe |
Rate of
Fe-source grams/tree |
||
|
Sequestrene 138 Fe-EDDHA |
6% |
150 |
300 |
450 |
|
Ferrostrene Fe-EDDHA |
6% |
150 |
300 |
450 |
|
Chelene Fe-EDDHA |
6.8% |
130 |
260 |
390 |
|
|
5% |
180 |
360 |
540 |
|
FeSO4-7H20 |
20% |
45 |
90 |
135 |
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Records taken in February 1981 show the degree of
chlorosis of the experimental trees before any treatment (Table 1). Ratings of iron
deficiency symptoms after treatment were made between August 1981 and February
1983 (Table 1).
It has been observed that within about two months
after treatment (August 1981) there was a marked decrease in iron deficiency
symptoms on all trees regardless of treatment, but trees receiving iron rated
better than the control (Table 1.)
The quickest and more nearly complete recovery from chlorosis was obtained with Sequestrene
138. This improved tree condition remained fairly constant for trees receiving Sequestrene 138, whereas control and trees receiving the
other Fe-sources did not show the same picture. In autumn and winter, iron
deficiency symptoms increased on these trees.
In all recording dates, Sequestrene
138 gave the best results at all three rates. Even trees receiving the lowest
rate of Sequestrene 138 completely recovered from chlorosis (Table 1, Figure 1).

FIGURE 1. Effect of different Fe-sources on chlorotic avocado trees.
Trees receiving other Fe-sources continued to have
the iron chlorosis symptoms, and in the second year
of the experiment are without any remarkable improvement. Almost no significant
differences were found between the degree of chlorosis
of these trees and the control.
|
Table 1. Mean degree of chlorosis of Hass avocado trees receiving different
Fe-sources of three different rates. |
|||||||||
|
Treatments |
February
1981 |
August
1981 |
October 1981 |
December
1981 |
February
1982 |
August
1982 |
October
1982 |
December 1982 |
February
1983 |
|
Sequestrene 138 - 150g |
6.1a* |
1.7ab |
1.1ab |
1.3a |
1.6a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
|
Sequestrene 138 - 300g |
6.3a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
|
Sequestrene 138 - 450g |
6.5a |
1.4a |
1.0a |
1.1a |
1.2a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
1.0a |
|
Ferrostrene - 150g |
6.0a |
2.2abc |
2.1abcd |
4.2b |
5.0b |
4.1b |
3.3ab |
3.6ab |
4. 1ab |
|
Ferrostrene - 300g |
6.2a |
2.1abc |
2.3abcd |
3.6ab |
5.2b |
3.4b |
3.7ab |
3.7ab |
4.6b |
|
Ferrostrene - 450g |
6.2a |
1.4a |
1.7abc |
2.3ab |
3.0ab |
3.8b |
4. 1ab |
4.2ab |
4.7b |
|
|
5.9a |
3.3bc |
3.6cd |
5.2b |
6.6b |
5.1b |
5.3b |
5.4b |
6.2b |
|
|
5.9a |
2.0abc |
2.9abcd |
4.2b |
5.4b |
4.9b |
4.7b |
4.4b |
5.7b |
|
|
5.9a |
2.5abc |
2.7abcd |
5.0b |
6.3b |
5.0b |
5.2b |
5.1b |
5.9b |
|
Chelene - 130g |
5.9a |
1.7ab |
2.1abcd |
3.0ab |
3.8ab |
4.6b |
3.6ab |
3.3ab |
3.4ab |
|
Chelene - 260g |
6.0a |
1.9ab |
2.2abcd |
4.4b |
5.3b |
4.3b |
4.7b |
4.8b |
5.6b |
|
Chelene - 390g |
6.2a |
1.9ab |
2.3abcd |
4.2b |
5.3b |
3.6b |
3.0ab |
3.2ab |
4.2ab |
|
FeSO4
• 7H20 - 45g |
6.2a |
2.7abc |
2.8abcd |
5.1b |
6.2b |
5.6b |
5.2b |
5.0b |
6.3b |
|
FeSO4
• 7H20 - 90g |
5.9a |
2.8abc |
3.2bcd |
4.9b |
6.2b |
4.8b |
4.8b |
5.2b |
5.7b |
|
FeS04
• 7H20 - 135g |
5.9a |
1.6a |
2.0abcd |
2.8ab |
4. 1ab |
4.2b |
5.1b |
6.3b |
5.6b |
|
Control |
6.1a |
3.7c |
4.0d |
5.1b |
6.5b |
5.2b |
4.6b |
4.9b |
5.8b |
|
S.E. |
|
0.524 |
0.628 |
0.884 |
1.061 |
0.885 |
1.059 |
1.018 |
1.063 |
|
C.V.
% |
|
74.26 |
81.47 |
73.78 |
69.81 |
65.04 |
83.19 |
78.52 |
71.65 |
|
* See rating scale in Material and
Methods. Values are means of nine trees. Means in the same column with the
same letter are not significantly different (P<0.05). |
|||||||||
The degree of chlorosis of
the individual trees in each replication during the last recording date of
February 1983 is shown in Table 2. Observing this table, it is obvious that
there is a high variability of the degree of chlorosis
between trees. Except from the treatments of Sequestrene
138 where all trees were healthy, in all other treatments and the control there
were trees from all four categories: healthy, slightly, moderately, and
severely chlorotic. The same picture was in all
recording dates. (Table 2).
|
Table 2. Degree of chlorosis of
individual avocado trees, Hass variety, receiving different Fe-sources at
three rates. [Recording date: February 1983]. |
|||||||||
|
|
Repl. |
||||||||
|
Treatments |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
|
Sequestrene 138 - 150g |
1* |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
|
Sequestrene 138 - 300g |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
|
Sequestrene 138 - 450g |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
|
Ferrostrene - 150g |
4 |
3 |
1 |
10 |
3 |
2 |
9 |
1 |
4 |
|
Ferrostrene - 300g |
1 |
8 |
9 |
1 |
4 |
8 |
3 |
4 |
3 |
|
Ferrostrene - 450g |
1 |
1 |
2 |
1 |
8 |
9 |
9 |
7 |
4 |
|
|
8 |
1 |
4 |
3 |
8 |
1 |
10 |
10 |
11 |
|
|
1 |
7 |
3 |
5 |
3 |
1 |
10 |
11 |
10 |
|
|
5 |
1 |
1 |
9 |
5 |
11 |
10 |
10 |
1 |
|
Chelene - 130g |
1 |
2 |
4 |
2 |
1 |
1 |
8 |
9 |
3 |
|
Chelene - 260g |
3 |
1 |
9 |
9 |
4 |
3 |
10 |
3 |
8 |
|
Chelene - 390g |
1 |
| |||||||